Photo by nikkicookiebaker
I am about a third of the way through this book and have dipped in and out of many sections and already I can quite confidently recommend it to you as a great resource. A couple of weeks ago I honestly never imagined I'd open a review of this book with anything approaching those words. I'd had a look on Amazon and read the reviews which alternate between loving India Knight in every way possible and gushing with delight, to those who claim to find her patronising and more than a bit clueless about the real world.
I will freely admit I expected to tell you that this was the painfully embarassing ramblings of a rich woman who'd just realised that money does not magically sprout from your purse and was passing on this handy tidbit to the rest of us, blissfully unaware that we were already more than ten miles further down the road. Better get on and justify myself then:
India Knight writes really well. Some people may take issue with this and object to the casual language she uses (refering to things as "crap" or "twattish", for example). If you feel that to write well means only adhering firmly to all rules of grammar and syntax and spurning the use of any form of slang then you may well disagree with me and not enjoy this book. Personally I find her really easy to read and very funny. And those are two attributes that are very welcome in a book full of facts and website addresses and advice. Her book reads like you are chatting with your funniest friend.
This is in contrast to Kath Kelly's writing style (see previous post), and to be fair to her as far as I could make out Kath was not a writer and had never tried to be a writer. She ended up producing her book as the first hand account of the person who'd lived her remarkable project and that gives it it's own value. However, as I mentioned in my previous review her writing was sometimes "clunky" and a trifle awkward, to the point where it did detract a little because it was so noticeable in places. It did give it a thrifty hand made feel I suppose.
Photo by Allim
Many of the scoffing reviewers of India's book dismiss it by saying there is nothing here they didn't know already, or laugh at the sections on "how to knit". Come on people, didn't your mum tell you that no-one likes a know-all? Each chapter is broken down into smaller sections and there are plenty of headings and highlighted boxes, so if you find yourself reading through something that you either know all about because it happened to be your masters dissertation or something that just doesn't interest you at all it is the easiest thing in the world to skip on to a section you do want to concentrate on. No-one is insisting that you read from cover to cover. Its a dip in where you need book.
I think its quite a plus that really really basic things are in the book. If you are a dab hand at knitting or have run a swapping scheme for years you have probably forgotten all about what it felt like to not know where to start or how to do a single simple thing.
And I think it is the sheer amount of facts and references to great websites and blogs that makes this such a potentially useful book. For example, I know quite a lot about craft and have frequented the majority of the inspirational blogs, but there were still enough new ones listed in this book to keep me quite happily occupied for an afternoon.So I would challenge those dismissive all-knowing reviewers to read their expert subject section properly and in full - I'd be surprised if there wasn't something new there even for them.
Others mock India for being the spoilt little rich girl who has never really known hardship and recommends a few expensive things like organic meat. I thought I would be one of them, but there is nothing more charming than someone who is fully aware of their own limitations (and the opinions others hold of those limitations) and can both freely admit to them and gently mock themselves. She is self-aware, and also quite clear that while she wants to save money she also wants some quality, some comfort, some nice things too. And that dear friend is about balance, and is about the very thing the Comfort Blanket espouses. We want to be warm and happy, not living on a diet of twigs or spending five weeks glueing lollipop sticks together to make a coffee table and not stressing over how close bankruptcy is.
As with any book of this type, you take the things that are useful to you and leave the rest behind. You will never, ever find a 'frugality' book that is full to the brim of new and unknown tips, and miracle 3-step solutions. Every single one will contain the blindingly obvious, the things a small child could achieve and the dull plodding common sense things that are necessary and unavoidable. But within those chapters each one will have other ideas that may be obvious to others but have slipped you by, or ideas that you need to hear explained in a new way to find their resonance with you. Its easy as pie to mock and go through list after list scoffing "who on earth wouldn't know that?". Urm, well, lets face it, if everyone knew and practised these ideas we may not be in half the pickle we are in just now.
I have heard many of these things before but sometimes reading it anew prompts you to try again. Its like dieting - we all know the fundamentals, eat less of the bad things, the right amount of the good things and do some exercise ("who on earth wouldn't know that?") but from the massive sales of diet books we clearly don't object to be told that simple message over and over.
This won't be everyone's cup of tea, I accept that. If you are allergic to anyone who has money then don't pick up this book and give yourself hives. If you yearn to go live in a commune and milk bees and live on nettle soup, try another book. But I like it. I have borrowed my copy from the library but I may very well go out and buy my own copy of "The Thrift Book - Live well and spend less" by India Knight to keep for future reference.

Recent Comments